Author:
Amy Whitehead
Design, Production
& Technical Assistance:
Cheri Sanders
This publication was funded in part through a grant by the Wisconsin Council on Developmental Disabilities in collaboration with the Waisman Center University Affiliated Program, University of Wisconsin-Madison.
A Parent’s Guide to Home Health Care is not copyrighted. This document may be duplicated in part or in entirety. Following standards for publishing, the Wisconsin Council on Developmental Disabilities, the Waisman Center University Affiliated Program, University of Wisconsin-Madison and Amy Whitehead request full acknowledgment in print anytime this information is reproduced.
Cite As:
Whitehead, A. (2000). A Parent’s Guide to Home Health Care. Madison,
WI: The Wisconsin Council on Developmental Disabilities and the Waisman Center,
University of Wisconsin-Madison.
To order more copies
of this document, contact:
Wisconsin Council on Developmental Disabilities
600 Williamson Street
P.O. Box 7851
Madison, WI 53707-7851
Phone: (608) 266-7826
FAX: (608) 267-3906
E-Mail: wiswcdd@dhfs.state.wi.us
Web Site: http://www.wcdd.org/
Acknowledgments
Preface
Introduction
Defining Home Health Care
Looking for Home Care
Seeking Approval for Home Care
Making Home Health Care Work for You
The development of this booklet
would not have been possible without the incredible information and insights
graciously shared by many across the state of Wisconsin. A heartfelt thank you
to the parents who were willing to be open with highly personal stories of their
own successes and struggles with home health care.
Nancy Anderson Beth Swedeen Janice Cooney David and Sherry Bishop Leslie Grant John Miller Liz Hecht Jackie Philpot JoEllen Kilkenny Cathy Twomey Gwen Lee Marina Van DeGraff Mary Musk Steve Verriden Special thanks to Caroline Hoffman,
Howard Mandeville, of the Wisconsin Council on Developmental Disabilities, and
Linda Tuchman, of the Waisman Center Early Intervention Program, for their encouragement
in initially acknowledging the importance of this project, offering support
to secure funding and providing me with critical feedback with the review of
the final drafts.
Many parents, providers and state
administrators were involved in the review process of this document. Their open
willingness to provide careful and insightful review enhanced the outcome tremendously.
Many thanks to all of the reviewers for their time and expertise: Acknowledgments
Community Living Alliance
Madison, Wisconsin
Wisconsin Personnel Development Project
Parents as Leaders (Statewide)
Parent
Verona, Wisconsin
Parents
Appleton, Wisconsin
Parent
Madison, Wisconsin
Parent
West Bend, Wisconsin
Parent
Belleville, Wisconsin
Catalyst Home Health
Madison, Wisconsin
Parent
Verona, Wisconsin
Parent
Appleton, Wisconsin
Parent
Ashland, Wisconsin
Community Living Alliance
Madison, Wisconsin
Parent
Greenfield, Wisconsin
Access to Independence
Madison, Wisconsin
Parents
Leslie Grant
Liz Hecht
Beth Swedeen
Waisman Center
University of Wisconsin-Madison
Pat Mitchell
Linda Tuchman
Wisconsin Coalition
for Advocacy
Jeffrey Spitzer-Resnick
Wisconsin Council
on Developmental Disabilities
Caroline Hoffman
Howard Mandeville
Jennifer Ondrejka
Wisconsin Department
of Health and Family Services
Bureau for Quality Assurance
Barbara Woodford
Division of Health
Care Financing
Division Staff
Division of Supportive
Living
Sinikka McCabe
Wisconsin Personal
Care Association
Nancy Anderson
This is a booklet about the strengths
of families. All parents grow with their children, but parents of children with
complex health needs develop an extraordinary array of new abilities as they
immerse themselves in their child’s care. Building collaborative relationships
with home health care providers to enhance the ability of their children to
participate as fully as possible in all aspects of family and community life
is among the most important of these new skills.
This is also a booklet about a system.
A home care system primarily structured to serve acutely ill adults that must
operate within a bewildering maze of regulations in a highly competitive economic
environment. Sadly, parents too often find themselves forced to struggle with
arcane rules governing such things as eligibility and hours and restrictions
they inevitably learn that they must assertively advocate for the services their
child needs and that there is great value in joining with others to advocate
for changes in policy that will reconfigure the system in family-centered ways.
A Parent’s Guide to Home Health
Care makes a powerful contribution to the families of Wisconsin by providing
accurate and practical information about home health care. But perhaps more
importantly, it also offers a compelling vision of the unique partnerships that
can make home care successful. Parents are recognized as experts on their child
and on the rhythm of life in their household; and home health workers are valued
for the knowledge, sensitivity and perspective they bring into the home along
with their direct care. This booklet emphasizes that they are essential allies,
sharing responsibility for creating an environment of support that nurtures
the well being of all- child, family, and care providers.
William Schwab, M.D.Preface
University of Wisconsin
Department of Family Medicine
Parent of a child with special health care needs
For Charlie, whose resiliency and inner strength keep me learning and loving all along the way.
We are living in a time when there are multiple demands on the American family. The two-parent family with a single wage earner is increasingly rare. Most families are stressed, overworked and struggle to make ends meet. Families who have children with disabilities are even more busy as they work to ensure that their children receive the appropriate support services. This journey of raising a child with special needs requires extraordinary time and energy, extending miles beyond "normal" parenting into a territory previously unknown. There is no doubt about this. Each parent must become a consumer of vast amounts of knowledge and information, learner of a whole new set of skills, master of a completely different language, and traveler on the emotional roller coaster of hope, despair and reward.
Given this, accurate information on home health care should be available to families, since it is one service that can alleviate some of the stress that families face. By utilizing home health care, a parent’s time and energy are more readily available. Home health care, an important service option when raising a child with a disability, is often unused or underutilized because of lack of accurate information or resources.
The home health care industry has primarily been built in response to an aging population and a decrease in lengthy hospital stays. Homemaker-home health aides are predicted to be one of the most rapidly growing occupations through 2006 (Occupation Outlook Handbook, 1998-99; HCFA, Health Care Financing Review, 1996; Department of Labor, Employment and Earnings, 1991-1995; U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics: Establishment Data, 1996). The industry is a combination of public and private organizations serving consumers by providing home health care typically billed to third party payers. Home health care is on the rise because it is often more economical to provide care at home instead of in a facility, and because people tend to do better emotionally and physically when they are in the comfort of their home (Buckingham, 1984). However, children with disabilities are an ever growing contingent of those in need of home health care.
This booklet is intended as a primer for families who want to learn more or who want to enhance their skills as consumers of home health care for their children. While the information in the guide pertains to all families who want to use home health care, a large amount of the information focuses on home health care funded through the Wisconsin Medicaid Program. The reason for this is that Medicaid is the largest single payer for home care for children. Therefore, Medicaid regulations and terminology will be described and the term "home care" will be used to be consistent with the Medicaid language. This overview will address the following aspects of home care:
This booklet will limit its focus to families with children under age 18, though many, if not most, of the issues, strategies and resources are applicable to a wide variety of individuals who require home care. The term "children" will be used to include: infants, toddlers, school-aged children, youth, and adolescents. The term "parent" refers to an individual in the primary caregiving role. Families are encouraged to learn more about home care and explore how it can enhance the quality of life for the entire family.
At the end of this booklet, three additional sections contain the following materials for families:
Defining Home Health Care
Home health care can broadly be defined
as services intended to improve or maintain a person’s quality of health primarily
within the individual’s home. Home health care may include assistance with the
everyday activities of life, such as eating, dressing and bathing and can also
include skilled assistance with life supporting devices. Hospice care and home-based
therapies, often considered home care, will not be addressed in this booklet.
Again, since Wisconsin Medicaid is the primary funder of home care, this section
will focus on definitions from Medicaid.
How does Home Care Differ from Respite?
Home care differs from respite, though in some cases the actual worker may be the same person. Respite workers may not need any formal training to provide care for a child, whereas a home care worker is required to have the appropriate training corresponding to the child’s care level. While respite can be provided in a setting outside of the home, such as a worker’s home, or a community or recreational site, home care takes place primarily in the home.
Additionally, respite and home care are supported by separate funding sources and agencies. Medicaid, for example, does not pay for respite. While these differences do exist, many similarities abound, and the information on these pages may be relevant to both approaches when seeking and securing care for a child.
What are Primary Home Care Providers?
Medicaid home care providers include home health and personal care agencies, as well as independent nurses, all of which provide individuals with care where they live. Home health agencies can be public or private, licensed by the state’s Bureau of Quality Assurance (BQA) and certified to participate in Medicare. Some home health agencies offer a variety of services including nursing, therapy, home health aide and personal care. A personal care agency can be a licensed home health agency, a county agency or an independent living center. Agencies differ widely in their philosophy, criteria and approach. It is wise for parents to research the agencies in their communities to determine which one(s) best matches their own style and need. Independent nurses may also be home care providers.
What are Home Care Services?
A wide variety of services can be provided by home care workers, depending on the individual’s level of need. Licensed professionals include nurses and therapists who provide skilled care, such as intravenous injections, under the direction of a physician. Home health aides, personal care workers and homemaker assistants assist with activities of daily living, such as dressing and bathing. In addition to assisting with activities of daily living, a personal care worker may provide assistance with medically oriented tasks if delegated by a registered nurse. Home health aides assist with medically oriented tasks that are needed to maintain the child’s health or treat a medical condition. It is important to emphasize that for all care levels, a registered nurse ensures supervision and coordination of the recipient’s care. Below is a brief summary of the primary home care services within the context of Medicaid-funded home care, as defined by the Department of Health and Family Services:
Skilled Nursing Services Registered Nurse (RN) or Licensed Practical Nurse (LPN)
Skilled nursing is divided into two categories, based on the number of hours of care a child receives. Home health skilled nursing, also called part-time intermittent nursing, is provided to recipients who require less than eight hours of direct skilled care per day. Private duty nursing is provided for individuals who require eight or more hours a day of skilled care. Both types of nursing tend to supplement the care provided by informal support systems, including other members of the child’s family. Sections 107.11(1)(c), 107.11(2)(a) and 107.12(1)(a) of the administrative code define skilled nursing. The Reference and Resource section of this guide contains a detailed brochure from the Department of Health and Family Services on Medicaid private duty nursing.
Home Health Aide Services
The Wisconsin Administrative Code defines home health aide services as: "medically oriented tasks, assistance with activities of daily living and incidental household tasks required to facilitate the treatment of a recipient’s medical condition or to maintain the recipient’s health." (WI Administrative Code, HFS 107.11 (1)(b)).
Personal Care
Wisconsin Medicaid defines personal care services as: "medically oriented activities related to assisting a recipient with activities of daily living necessary to maintain the recipient in his or her place or residence in the community." (WI Administrative Code, HFS 107.112(1)a).
The difference between a home health aide and a personal care worker is based primarily on training, responsibility, child’s complexity of care and level of medically oriented tasks. Home health aides are certified nursing assistants who have received a minimum of 75 hours of training and an annual in-service training. Personal care workers are required to have a minimum of 40 hours of training in the provision of personal care services. In general, a home health aide is prepared to carry out more medically oriented tasks such as gastrostomy-tube (g-tube) feedings and giving medications. A personal care worker focuses more on bathing, dressing and simple transfers. Licensed and certified home health agencies are required to comply with additional federal and state requirements that do not apply to personal care agencies. Home health aides often provide short-term visits to individuals transitioning from hospital to home. The important aspect for both categories of home care worker is the involvement of a nurse who delegates responsibility and supervises the care provided as often as necessary.
Clarifying the distinctions between home health aides and personal care workers is important for families to understand since it can be confusing and affects the care families receive. Each nurse and the associated agency provider decides what level of care it is willing to delegate to the direct home care worker. Some nurses and agencies will not delegate medically-oriented tasks to a personal care worker, while others will. The result is that any two parents with similar children receiving services from two different agencies may receive home care workers in different categories. In short, when a nurse delegates a task to a worker, her nursing license is on the line and this is one reason for the variability in home care service categories.
How is the Level of Care Decided?
A family’s initial assessment will involve questions about the child’s level of care and this information will help to determine the type of care needed (e.g., personal care versus skilled nursing) and the number of hours of coverage. Each child is evaluated individually. It is important to emphasize that Medicaid covered services are the same throughout the state of Wisconsin. The variation across the state as to what each child receives for home care appears to be contingent not just on the child’s needs, but also on how the agency decides to assume responsibility for the child’s care. A covered personal care service, for example, is: "Meal preparation, food purchasing and meal serving," 107.112 (1)(b)11. One family comments:
"It takes my child so long to eat. Most kids eat lunch in 15 minutes, but it can take us easily an hour to feed Chris. To prepare his meal takes even more time because we have to buy special high-calorie items, then specially prepare the food, so he doesn’t choke on it. If he doesn’t get enough calories, he is likely to lose weight and get sick. And we have to hold him to feed him, since he cannot hold a spoon or sit up on his own and proper positioning is crucial so he doesn’t choke or aspirate on his food. So there is a lot of pressure on us to feed him well in an uninterrupted, safe manner."
In this situation a personal care worker would be trained to purchase the appropriate foods, prepare the food and feed Chris. If a child’s total meal time (preparation, feeding and clean-up) is one and a half hours, and the child eats three or five times a day, then potentially a personal care worker could be available for a total of five hours for feeding alone. Additionally, the child may need assistance with personal hygiene (bathing, tooth brushing, skin care, toileting) tasks that may require a total of another hour and a half each day. Now the family could potentially receive six and a half hours of personal care a day. Household chores that are incidental to personal care may account for one third of the Medicaid hours of care, but only certain tasks are allowed. Cleaning the kitchen after the child’s meal preparation is permitted, for example, but doing the parents’ laundry is not.
The cares described above could be met by a personal care worker. However, for children with serious medical conditions, skilled nursing care may be required. Airway care, for example, for a child with a tracheostomy, oxygen therapy and/or ventilator will require skilled nursing. Families may use creative approaches to supplementing Medicaid home care with other funding sources such as Medicaid waiver programs that have few restrictions on the medical necessity of the activities. For example a family may arrange for a personal care worker for meal time and then use Community Options Program (COP) funds to cover a trip to the mall.
How is Home Care Paid for?
Home care is expensive and typically paid for in one of several ways: private fee-for- service insurance or managed care plans; Medicaid/Medical Assistance; Community Option Program (COP), Community Integration Program (CIP); and out-of-pocket. Another option worth exploring is the Family Support Program in Wisconsin, a flexible funding source for families with children with disabilities living with their families. County programs which may help families are typically available through the county human services or community program agency. In the State of Wisconsin, most home care for children is funded through the Medicaid program. The Wisconsin Administrative Code (excerpts in reference section) delineates home care regulations, including a clear listing of covered and non-covered services. Parents will benefit from accessing a copy of this code from their public library, by ordering a copy of their own or by viewing it on the World Wide Web (see references). It is important to point out that each individual is initially assessed for home care eligibility and a level of care is determined before the care is authorized. In families where the child’s health fluctuates widely, it may be possible to have skilled nursing at times of extreme health risk and a personal care worker at times of relative stability.
What is Medicaid Prior Authorization?
Home care provided as a Wisconsin Medicaid covered service requires a physician’s order and prior authorization. The Wisconsin Administrative Code offers the following definition: "HFS 101.03(134) ‘Prior authorization’ means the written authorization issued by the department to a provider prior to the provision of a service. Note: Some services are covered only if they are authorized by the department before they are provided. Some otherwise covered services must be prior authorized after certain thresholds have been reached." It is important for parents to realize that the Medicaid home care prior authorization (PA) procedure involves several steps and may result in a delay or denial in the start-up of home care. First, the home health agency must complete the PA paperwork in a timely manner and then submit it to the Department of Health and Family Services, Bureau of Health Care Financing, which reviews the request. The PA may be returned to the provider if it is incomplete or has clerical errors. The provider must make the necessary changes and resubmit the PA. This cycle can occur several times if the provider’s information is incorrect or absent. Ultimately, the request for service is either approved, modified or denied. If it is approved, the provider is notified and informs the family that services may begin. If it is modified or denied, the parents will receive a letter from the department with their appeal rights outlined. The term "modified" indicates that the PA is approved with changes from the original request. The term "denied" indicates that the entire request was not approved. The Prior Authorization (PA) Process-Simplified outlines the prior authorization process in a simplified version.
"To tell you the truth, I don't really know how our home care is paid for. We are on several county programs and I am really confused about how different things are paid for."
The Prior Authorization (PA) Process - Simplified a a a a a a Parents request home health care services from provider (Provider is agency or independent provider)
Provider completes and sends in PA (Prior authorizations cover a specified period of time and must be resubmitted each time a requested service is to be extended)
State Medicaid office processes PA
If corrections or supplemental information is needed, PA is returned to provider, provider responds and returns PA to state, state Medicaid office again processes PA.
PA is Approved, Modified, or Denied
If Denied, family receives letter with appeal rights
Provider informs family of PA decision
Family outcome:
Either "approved" service begins, "modified" service begins, or "denied" service
is accepted or appealed. *** Modified may indicate a change from the original
PA request. For example, if 8 hours a day had been requested, a modified outcome
may mean approval for 6 hours a day.
Many children with disabilities qualify for Wisconsin Medicaid. Medicaid is
"a state/federal assistance program that helps certain needy and low-income
people pay their medical bills. It is also called Medical Assistance, Title
19, and T19." (State of Wisconsin, 1999). Medicaid can be accessed in a number
of ways and parents are encouraged to call Medicaid Recipient Services, (800)
362-3022, to learn more about how to apply. Medicaid is an invaluable resource
for families as they seek home care.
In some situations, county programs such as COP, CIP and/or Family Support
may supplement Medicaid services for the child’s non-medical needs. These county
programs are not insurance yet might have funds to partially support home care
depending on need and available funds. Parents can gain further information
about programs in their counties by calling their local County Human Services
office. Looking for Home Care
Know Your Funding Because of the high
cost of home care, most families will rely on insurance to cover the cost. Before
you begin the search for home care, it is wise to evaluate what insurance coverage
you have for your child. A call to your private insurance company, if you have
private insurance, will help to clarify what services they do or do not cover.
Most private insurance companies do not provide long-term home care coverage.
This information may also be available in the health insurance policy booklet.
Identify an Agency
There are many ways to identify the home care agencies in your community. Below is a list of sources of information:
Contact the Agency
Families should identify and contact their local home health agencies and find out more about each program. Before calling, think about questions you would like to ask. Below is a sample protocol for your initial contact with a home health agency:
At this point, if the agency says they do not have available personnel to meet your needs, call another home health agency in your area. This may feel disappointing after the energy and time you spent preparing for this call. You can call other home health agencies or work with another program, such as the Family Support or Community Options Program to explore other ways to find home care.
If, however, the agency indicates that they may be able to assist you, consider asking the following questions:
Questions to Ask the Agency
The positive outcome of the phone call may be that a home visit is set up at a mutually agreeable time. This visit will most likely entail an hour or two of your time, during which you share information about your child’s disability, care needs and other relevant information. You will also be asked to give the name, address and phone number of your child’s primary physician so that a doctor’s order can be obtained. The home care agency representative who does the assessment is usually a registered nurse.
A less desirable outcome from the phone call is the realization that you are not able to work with the agency. When this occurs it is best to begin again and search for alternative agencies or alternative plans. While this may feel discouraging, it is better to learn up front that an agency cannot meet your needs, rather than learn it a year down the road when a large amount of energy and time has been invested.
Nurses in Independent Practice
Medicaid-certified nurses, who are not affiliated with an agency, are an option for families with a child who requires eight or more hours a day of skilled nursing. If nursing services are not available to a family through a home health agency, then an independent nurse may provide the services. There are benefits and risks for families who hire an independent nurse. The benefits are that the agency as a third party is eliminated and therefore the communication is between the family and nurse alone. However, this also puts a burden on the family to be solely responsible for recruitment, background checks, training, supervision and a back-up plan. The level of risk to the family is magnified by the lack of outside support, especially if something should go wrong (e.g., poor performance, unethical behavior). Families need to consider the potential associated costs for unemployment and worker’s compensation should a nurse be asked to leave or acquire an injury on the job. Parents are strongly encouraged to do their homework before hiring an independent nurse, asking many questions of the applicant and the references. Below are a few questions to consider:
Questions to Consider
Prior Authorization
Upon completion of the agency’s assessment for home care, there is a period of time when families must wait to hear whether or not the requested service has been approved. This process may take a few weeks and it may be hard to wait.
While Medicaid home care is a covered service in Wisconsin, the process of Prior Authorization is required as a quality control measure to evaluate the requested service and ensure the appropriate use of funds. When reviewing a provider’s prior authorization request, the Department of Health and Family Services considers medical necessity, appropriateness, cost, frequency, quality, timeliness, alternatives and other related areas. Prior authorization is described in greater detail in the Administrative Code section HFS 107.02(3). A detailed handout from the Department, Private Duty Nursing, (see reference section) also describes in clear detail the prior authorization process as it relates to private duty nursing.
Advocacy
It is important that parents have accurate information about home care and the Medicaid requirements for prior authorization, covered and non-covered services. Families may also request copies of the prior authorization form and related materials from the home health agency so that they are "in the loop" of the process and will be better able to understand how the process progresses. The simplified prior authorization chart on page 9 shows how typically a parent requests a service and is generally then "out of the loop" until final notification is received. Many prior authorizations are returned to home health agencies due to clerical errors such as a missed digit in a number, a misspelling, or an unanswered question. A family may consider offering to review the document as a way to become better informed and to potentially catch minor clerical errors. Needless to say, parents need to consider how they asked to be involved so their interest is perceived as an offer of assistance and desire to be involved, as opposed to a suspicious assumption that the agency may have made mistakes. This point is especially important since the prior authorization process may be your first experience in working directly with the agency.
Complete and accurate information alone will not suffice, parents need to develop skills to advocate for their child when a request for prior authorization of a service is denied. Should a parent seek home care and be denied, there is a course of action to follow. Many families keep a notebook in which they log all phone calls, correspondences and meetings with providers and administrators. This is a useful tool to help you keep track of your efforts to seek home care and can be used to prepare your appeal. Other families have sought out the support of advocacy agencies to receive strategy advice or to get help in appealing. Still, other families have not kept records, nor contacted advocacy agencies and have independently worked with state administrators to build relationships. A parent’s search for one person within the system who listens carefully and expresses sensitivity for and a willingness to look into the situation, may result in an improved outcome for the family. These different approaches may reflect the past experiences which individual parents have had and not the individual’s ability to advocate positively.
There are several agencies in the state to offer information and support, and some to offer legal services, to families with children with disabilities:
"I could never have gotten the amount of nursing care I needed without the support from the advocacy community."
Advocacy Organizations
"In almost every
benefits program and civil rights statute directed toward individuals with disabilities,
Congress has included the right to individual appeal, first to a disinterested
decision-maker and thereafter, if necessary, to the courts."
- K. Seelman, Director National Institute on Disability and Rehabilitation Research
The References and Resources section contains detailed contact information for these agencies. There may also be additional advocacy organizations in local communities.
In addition, Section HFS 104.01 of the Administrative Code outlines the "Recipient rights." Section 104.01(5) "Appeals," delineates the steps to a fair hearing. If a prior authorization is modified or denied, the parent always receives a letter explaining the reasons for the decision and the options a parent may pursue. The Department of Health and Family Services, Division of Health Care Financing recommends the following options:
A Parent’s Rights
From: Wisconsin Medicaid, Private Duty Nursing: A Guide for Medicaid Recipients and Their Families, POH 1122, April 1999.
Overall, families have benefited from formal and informal advocacy routes by building positive relationships with advocates, home care agencies, and state administrators. Effective people skills, coupled with a strong knowledge base, enhance the ability to meet the needs of your child and family. The following suggestions are offered to parents:
Ways to Build Your Advocacy Skills
The following sections in this guide are based on the assumption that you have located a home care agency, received approval for funding and that you are now ready to get a worker on board.
To prepare this booklet, information
was gathered from written materials as well as interviews and focus groups providing
input from families who are currently using home care for their children with
special needs. Agency providers and state administrators also gave generously
of their time and expertise. From this research, critical findings surface around
four central themes: information, recruitment, training, and retention. This
section reviews the findings and examines the challenges of these central themes
as well as strategies to address the challenges. Making Home Care Work for You
Information
Increasingly, families are gaining
information about home care and accessing it. The proven benefits of respite
care, which is a more familiar program to families in Wisconsin, have paved
the way for families’ comfort with leaving their children in another person’s
care. However, there is a need for clear and accurate information to be made
more readily available to families.
Families report that they have limited
amounts of information about home care. Many do not know that the Wisconsin
Administrative Code outlines covered and non-covered services for Medicaid recipients.
Many say that they have never seen a copy of the administrative code. Many commented
on a general feeling of confusion about which federal, state or local program
funds their child’s home care. Additionally, across the state there appears
to be a wide range of "interpretations" of exactly what families are eligible
for in terms of home care for their children. Clearly, information is variable
across the state and parents are often told different things depending on whom
they talk to. The age of the child seems to be an important criterion in some
counties. For example, if an infant or toddler cannot typically dress him or
herself, an agency may decide that the child does not qualify, citing "parenting"
as a non-covered service. While it is true that all very young children require
assistance with activities of daily living, a very young child with a disability
may require care that far exceeds "normal" parenting. Parents are encouraged
to seek the services, one of which may be home care, that will enable them to
better meet the needs of all members of their family.
Still other families report that
home care was available because both parents or a single parent work outside
the home. The number of hours of service seemed to be connected to the parents’
employment, though it is interesting to point out that the regulations for home
care do not indicate this variable as part of the eligibility criteria. This
question stems from the definition of medical necessity HFS 101.03(96m), which
states that Medicaid provides services that identify, prevent or treat a condition
and that the service meets a set of standards for appropriate care. The Division
of Health Care Financing states that parent availability and ability is considered
in the approval process. For example, if a parent has a disability, this may
allow for more home care for her child with a disability since she is restricted
in her ability to provide care. For families, it is crucial that a lot of detailed
information is given to the home health agency so that those reviewing the prior
authorization process have a clear picture of the actual situation.
Recruitment
Finding quality workers to work in home care for a child with a disability
is a common struggle for families. Several challenges and strategies are addressed
below.
Challenges:
Families report that finding high quality, trustworthy people to work in home care is an overwhelming challenge. Many times, families are eligible for home care and yet may have either chronic or intermittent problems in finding care workers.
The Barriers to Finding Care Workers
"I want people to see my child for who she is, not for her disability."
Strategies:
While it can be a challenge to find home care workers whom you can trust and value, there are some successful strategies that families have shared. Families should consider how they find care workers. Is it out of your control or do you have a significant role to play? By taking an active role in choosing a home care worker, by investing time and energy up front, you are more likely to have a successful outcome.
Parents across the state have discovered a creative assortment of recruitment strategies. One mother always selects a home care worker through word-of-mouth by someone she trusts who has recommended the individual. One family sends a personal letter to friends, asking if they know of anyone who might be interested in working with their child. Other parents ask the home health agency for a few names and then initiate telephone screening and direct-contact interviews. Some parents have tapped into the availability of a close relative who would rather do meaningful work with a nephew than a shift job. Families living near colleges and universities have posted their personalized job announcements on bulletin boards in targeted departments (e.g., nursing, physical therapy, special education). Recruitment may be out of a parent’s control depending on the home health agency’s policy. Yet even if there is no parental control over the recruitment process, it is important for each family to take some time considering what qualities they would like to see in a home care worker. Parents may benefit from asking themselves the following questions before they seek a worker:
Know What You Want
What to Include in a Job Description
Sample Job Description.
Home care worker, $8/hr, 3-7 pm daily. Provide care in our home for our 8-year-old daughter with a physical disability. Looking for an energetic, thoughtful, sensitive individual to assist with activities of daily living (dressing, feeding, bathing). A great opportunity for those preparing for the "helping" professions. On bus line. Call Helen at 333-0409, evenings.
Once you have completed and posted the job description, phone calls will come. Or if an agency is pre-selecting care workers, you may still receive calls from a pool of potential care workers. (Note: some families may not be provided with input into this process through agency policy.) Being prepared for the calls with a telephone screening approach will make this process easier.
What to Ask During a Telephone Screening
What to Ask During an Interview
(Can be mixed into conversation or asked as discrete questions)
During the interview, the parent should make sure that the applicant has complete information, so there is an understanding of what is involved in caring for his/her child on good and bad days. Families repeatedly emphasize the importance of being up-front with potential care workers, believing that if the worker chooses to stay knowing the full range of the child’s situation, then the worker will be prepared and do a better job. If a child has episodic bouts with illness, self-abusive behavior, pain or other health conditions that come and go, it benefits all involved if these episodes are clearly addressed early on in the process. A parent may say to an applicant: There will be days when my son cries almost all day and try as I may, I can’t help him feel better. These days will be very frustrating and sad. There will also be days when he is feeling great, laughs out loud and wants to get involved in the world around him.
Knowing your own values and how those relate to household practices is something to share as part of the interview process. For example, if television is restricted in hours or days this should be clear up-front. The parents’ approach to discipline should be stated and an applicant needs to be comfortable in following through on the parents’ approach, not their own. Religious beliefs are highly personal and parents may choose to ask the applicant about whether or not his/her religious beliefs will potentially be in conflict with the families approach to daily life. For example, in one family a child participates in yoga, and the personal care worker has refused to be involved in this due to her personal religious beliefs. The level of cleanliness in a home can at times conflict with an applicant’s personal standards. Again, addressing these issues in the very beginning and using the information gathered as part of the selection process can alleviate conflicts down the road.
In the example provided earlier, where the parent shares that there are days when she cannot console her child, the parent understands that patience, an easy-going style and understanding are crucial characteristics for working with children who are medically complicated.
Things to Look for During an Interview
What to Think About During an Interview
After you have interviewed the available workers, think about each one and try to envision him or her in your home and with your child. Ask your children what they thought of the applicants. While you ideally want the best qualified worker, parents report that there may be times when they have to "settle for less," because the need for home care is so great that for a short-term solution, something is better than nothing. This is important because lack of home care may result in a parent’s need to stay home, creating a loss of employment. In the attendant guide Working Together (1998), the authors caution: "Beware of Being Too Choosy," pointing out that part of the process of obtaining and securing home care is dependent on some compromises. It is crucial for families to identify those pieces of the puzzle they are willing to relinquish (e.g., exact hours preferred), and those that cannot be compromised (e.g., safety). A long-term lack of home care may also result in harm to the child, either through unavoidable neglect or general inability to provide quality care because of other competing commitments. A lack of long-term home care may also result in harm to the caregiver, whether through physical or emotional strain.
Follow-Up
Typically the home health agency will obtain references, yet you may also wish to ask the applicant for two references. You may want to say: I really feel positive about the experience you bring to this position. I always ask applicants for two to three references just as part of this process. Could you provide me with references, perhaps including one person who has known you for a long time? Some applicants will need to call you back with phone numbers and names. When you contact the reference, below are some sample questions to consider. Be sure to begin by clearly identifying yourself, your reason for calling, and ask if this is a good time to talk. Be sure to close by thanking the reference for his/ her time and information.
What Questions to Ask a Reference
Once a new home care worker is ready to take care of your child in your home, you need to consider how best to orient the worker. While home health agencies take some responsibility for this activity, many parents opt to be actively involved. The training may include highly individualized information not only about your child’s condition, but also about where equipment, medications, and other supplies are kept within the home. The home care notebook (in Appendix A), which many parents develop as a way to share information about their children, is a useful tool when explaining your child’s needs. Often there is a large amount of information for the worker to learn at first and many people have trouble retaining volumes of information when it is given in a short period of time. Therefore, the book provides a written statement of need and can be referred to over time. The book is also a place to record ongoing changes and information.
Parents report they often engage the previous or existing home care worker in training the new worker. This strategy serves two purposes: it frees the parents’ time to do other activities, and it offers the worker perspective to the new employee. For a new home care worker to hear the same information from two different perspectives will enhance his/her understanding and better prepare him/her for the job. This strategy may not be supported by the home care agency, in terms of paying two workers at the same time. A family could ask if they are allowed to use other funds, (e.g., COP, CIP, Respite), to pay one of the workers during the training period.
Parents emphasize the importance of being up-front with the new worker and sharing information openly. Working side-by-side with the new worker offers you a chance to create a conversational approach to training. You may demonstrate a procedure and then say, "Would you like to try now?" Ask how they think it went and then provide your feedback. After the new worker has demonstrated the ability to provide care, staying close by and available for the first few weeks will increase the quality of the training. Listening to the new worker and the child while at work in another room is a useful way to monitor the situation and also allows you to intervene when necessary. For example, many children will test a new worker, and the parent’s role is to inform the care worker about what is acceptable behavior and what is not. Parents need to look for the quality of the worker’s performance.
Ways to Evaluate Performance
Frequent and clear feedback during the orientation phase will likely improve the overall success of the match. It is a good idea to "check-in" at the end of each day during the initial orientation phase. Ask if the worker has any questions or concerns. It is harder to give critical feedback after the training phase. Below are several suggestions for developing your own role as a trainer of new home care workers.
How You Can Teach the New Worker the Job
Challenges:
Parents can play an active role in retention- the process of keeping a home care worker, working with your child. Retention is dependent on many variables, some of which are beyond the family’s control. Being aware of retention issues can help you understand home care more clearly and give you a sense of what is within your control and what is not.
Situations may occur that have nothing to do with the family. For example, many parents report that an ongoing struggle with home care is that the direct care worker may be suddenly switched by the agency, resulting in a brand new worker showing up at the family’s door. In this situation, families report feeling unwilling to leave their children with a stranger and feel frustrated by the poor communication flow between agency and family. Retaining a home care worker also depends on what you as a family do to actively nurture the relationship and match. Once you have secured a worker, the need for close attention to the situation is critical to the success of the home care.
As a parent, you may want to monitor the care worker’s satisfaction with the job. The following indicators may be signs that your worker is dissatisfied or otherwise questioning his/her job.
If you feel that the match is not working out well, communication with the home care worker is crucial. When a family would like to let a care worker go after realizing that it is not a good match and/or the child’s welfare is at stake, this can be done with the support of the home care agency.
When you lose a care worker, understanding why you lost him or her can help you to move past the feelings of disappointment and sadness you may experience.
Some of the greatest challenges faced by parents are found when workers suddenly, and often unexpectedly, leave the job. Sometimes they will provide notice, sometimes not. Sometimes a worker may simply not show up and that is the way you are informed of the resignation. This is often hard for families since parents may question themselves and perceive this as a personal failure. Children also may feel hurt when a care worker calls to resign, instead of coming to the home to say good-bye. Finding ways to talk about this with your children is also important so they understand that it was nothing that they did, and reassuring them that family will always love them and be there for them.
Some Common Signs of Job Dissatisfaction
There is no way around the hurt feelings that naturally surface for many families when they suddenly lose a worker. Healing emerges from a careful review of what occurred and an objective understanding of why the worker left. Periodic self-evaluation of your own behaviors is important to the ongoing process of improving your own communication and management skills. And there are times when we all make regrettable mistakes.
For many parents, there is comfort in understanding why a match did not work out. Many times it just was not a good match and no one is to blame. Families may again refer to the Wisconsin Medicaid Administrative Code, which delineates rules about discharge. Agencies discharging clients have their own rules, yet also need to follow the code regarding giving notice, HFS 105.16(10)(f), 105.19(9) and 107.112(3)(b). In general, licensed Medicaid certified home health agencies must inform the parents if a service is discontinued and assist parents to find another agency for that same service. These guidelines are outlined in section HSS 133 of the Administrative Code and the Bureau of Quality Control governs this area. Families can file complaints if necessary and may begin by calling the Medicaid Recipient Hotline.
Strategies:
To ensure the success of the match, parents report that communication is the key. Some families keep a communication notebook, where all information is shared between home, school and community. This allows the home care workers to see the child as a complete person across environments. One family asks all workers to initial the notes after reading them to ensure that everyone stays in the information loop. Other parents develop "goals for the day," or checklists that are updated daily to confirm that key activities are accomplished.
When families do encounter challenges to home care, the following approaches may help them address the problem before it results in an irreconcilable difference.
Ways to Address Concerns:
While communication around issues of the child’s care is critical, parents have also found that personalized communication with the worker is needed. Developing a relationship between a parent and worker increases the prospects of a mutually beneficial outcome. First, you as the parent are in a better position to foresee difficulties if you have frequent conversations with the worker. Asking questions about the worker’s life allows you to gain a sense of future plans, interests and strengths. You can then capitalize on any hobbies or special talents. This conversation also gives the worker the message that you care about him/her, that he/she is not just a person coming into your home to do a job. This mutual sharing and communicating is an essential component of an effective partnership.
Parents report that successful matches between parent and worker ultimately result in long-term relationships, a stronger bond between child and worker and increased trust and caring on both ends. Many families talk about a special worker who has stayed connected to their family for years. In these situations, the level of care sprouts from deep roots; parents use the word "love" to describe the relationship. Families say that some workers feel like members of the family, acting as role models to their typically developing children and as trusted advocates. Acknowledging and demonstrating respect for workers is a key retention strategy according to families.
Ways to Acknowledge Workers
In addition, periodically self-evaluate your own behaviors. Are you showing the home care workers respect, flexibility and support? Are your expectations realistic? Remembering that possibly no one will ever do things as well as you, the parent, and letting go of expectations that the worker can read your child’s every movement and cry is necessary for home care to work. If your home care experience is marred by frustration, tension and a chronic feeling of dissatisfaction, then it is time to step back and talk with a trusted friend or professional about the situation. Overall, home care should be an enhancement to your life; and if it is not, you should carefully review the issues.
Ways to Show Respect for Workers
"Be careful what you ask for; you may get it."
"In my life, I don't have anything that is confidential anymore. We have no privacy."
Challenges and Benefits to Home Health Care
Challenges
Having another person to provide
care for your child at home is unquestionably a benefit for many families. The
benefit is countered by the challenge of the invasion of a very private zone,
your home. Your home is probably the one place where you can totally be yourself
and do things however you choose. Once you have home care in place, your home
becomes more public.
In a sense families are used to
this, since from early on we have frequently exchanged highly personal information
for services. Home care is an extension of the many times we have opened up
our lives to others in order to receive services. This opening is difficult
for many families and consumes a lot of energy in terms of planning, monitoring
and continuously improving the process. Parents say: "It takes a lot of energy
having others in your house;" "It needs a lot of attention;" and it is "draining,
exhausting, takes lots of emotional energy."
Holidays can be difficult times
for families, since it is common for workers to take personal vacations at this
time. However, parents report this inconvenience as part of the "give and take"
of the family-worker relationship.
Many families have experienced frustration
with the home care agencies, especially around the issue of communication. Families
have had concerns about the poor return on phone calls and responses to requests.
One family member commented that she felt her family was not a high priority
for the agency, which accounted for the poor communication. Another parent was
devastated by an agency’s attempt to take her to court for alleged child negligence.
Another challenge is the availability
or lack of home care workers and whether the parents are permitted to be involved
in the selection of the workers. On the other hand, many parents have excellent
experiences with their provider agencies, indicating that the quality of business
etiquette and philosophical framework varies widely from one agency to the next.
Several families report that they
stay with the same home care agency, despite dissatisfaction, because the thought
of "start-up" with a new agency is overwhelming. The issue of start-up exists
not only with switching agencies, but also with switching home care workers.
Initiating the process of start-up consumes huge amounts of energy. Parents
need to once again tell all the details of their child’s condition, explaining,
requesting. And ultimately, many parents feel the burden falls on them to initiate,
follow-up and ensure completion of the process. Building new relationships also
takes energy and time.
In families where there are siblings,
issues may arise that require further thought and action. Clearly, the covered
service of home care is limited to individuals who are eligible. However, while
in a family’s home it is often impossible to ignore the presence of siblings.
Parents need to honor the fact that the home care worker is there for the child
with special needs, yet there are ways to support sibling relationships. One
example is seen at mealtime when the whole family and the worker are at the
kitchen table. The worker may feed your child with a disability, yet your other
children are there as well and this may be a time to model sibling interaction.
Siblings may gravitate to a worker and compete for his/her attention. Parents
can offer support by their presence and by intervening when appropriate.
Benefits
If securing home care for your child
is difficult, why is there increasing interest and use of this service? Because
in the overall balance of the equation there are net benefits. Parents report
that the experience of receiving home care is highly positive because of the
relationships that are built and the actual care that is provided. Families
describe the incredible people who come into their lives, the role models for
typically developing children and the feeling of satisfaction in the power of
one person (your child) to create meaningful change in another person’s (care
worker’s) life. Parents clearly see that home care allows them to go to work,
get things done (e.g., errands, advocate, school meetings, other services),
and spend time with their other children.
In interviews with parents of children
in a Madison Medical Assistance personal care program, a study found: "Repeatedly
when I asked parents what personal care meant to them, they stated ‘my sanity.’"
(Van De Graaff, 1999). Further, parents report that home care allows them to
maintain an "age-appropriate" relationship with their child, since typical development
usually involves a gradual increase in independence, especially in personal
care. Parents also stated that the care needs of their children are so extensive
that it would be physically impossible to meet the child’s needs without help
from another person.
With time, parents gain experience
in how best to secure home care for their children. The process of obtaining
home care is one that generally improves over time as you, a parent, become
increasingly savvy and figure out how to meet the needs of your family. And
there is a sense of satisfaction in this skill as it develops. This booklet
is intended to share some of those strategies with families so that the wheel
does not need to be continuously recreated. However, you alone will discover
the nuances of home care and the details that work for you.
This booklet provides parents with
the appropriate information and supports for their care giving roles, in the
hope that they can exert more control over their choices and direction, thereby
ensuring meaningful and fulfilling lives. Appendix B offers a few reflection
pieces which may help parents think about their roles as caregivers. Home care
for children with significant disabilities is one approach to supporting families
so that parents maintain their health and success.
Parents’ Perspectives: Areas of Concern
Parents who are receiving services expressed gratitude for the help they have
received; they also recognized areas where the current system could be improved.
A few of these key areas of concern and corresponding questions are summarized
below: Worker Categories of Care: While each home health agency or personal
care agency follows the same Medicaid regulations for covered services, they
have some latitude in deciding which level of care to request for a child with
a long-term disability. This latitude is in part to allow the nurses to decide
what tasks can be delegated to a worker, and consequently what the nurse can
assume responsibility for. As a result, families with very similar children
may be receiving different services (e.g., nursing, home health aide, personal
care) depending on the agency they access. With many children surviving premature
or traumatic birth experiences and living longer lives, there are more children
with long-term needs who require skilled care for gastrostomy-tube (g-tube)
feedings and medications, for example. These are the children who seem to receive
greatest variability in the category of care.
Question: Is this variability acceptable or does it cause families to feel like the quality and extent of the services they receive have to do less with their child’s disability and more with where they live?
Parenting versus Extraordinary Caregiving: A parent’s care for a child with a disability is different from that of a worker in that typically it is fueled by an overwhelming sense of unconditional love. Yet the care that most children with significant disabilities require is extraordinary and can be distinguished from "normal" parenting by the amount of time and physical and mental energy it consumes. Medicaid regulations state that parenting is a non-covered service as part of the interpretation of the medical necessity regulation. Yet medical services are sometimes denied based on an interpretation of these services as "parenting."
Question: Is there a need to establish the differences between "normal" parenting and the parenting of a child with a significant disability to ensure that the two are not perceived as the same?
Care within the Home: Children with long-term disabilities have become increasingly involved in their local communities, participating in a wide variety of activities outside of the home, (e.g., parks, libraries, malls, business establishments, swimming pools, day cares). When these children leave the house to enter into community settings, their need for assistance (e.g., mobility, feeding, toileting, medications, suctioning) continues. The growing acceptance and push for community integration is inconsistent with the Medicaid regulations that largely limit personal care services to care within the home (with some exception).
Question: Do the societal trends toward community integration require personal care guidelines to be updated to allow for flexibility of where the service is received or do families need to be encouraged to creatively patch together various funding resources to meet their needs?
Allotment and Usage of Hours: Most families live highly dynamic lives that change with the time of year and the health of their children. While the home is the constant for families and the parents are the constant for their children, routines change with school schedules, hospitalizations and vacations. A child may be allotted eight hours of personal care a day. During the school year, an average of two hours a day is used. In the summer, however, the family needs ten hours a day if the parents work outside of the home and there is no summer school program.
Question: Are families adequately informed of their right to request a new prior authorization process every time their needs change (e.g., change in recipient’s or family’s situation) or have the current prior authorization amended to provide greater flexibility as needs change?
These questions indicate a need for future discussion between parents, workers and administrators on policy issues, especially around home care regulation. This booklet concludes with a call for future study, advocacy and quality assurance.
Tips and Tools
Create Your Own Home Health Care Book
Many families have created personalized home health care books for the providers who come into their homes. Here is a way to begin thinking about developing your own book.
Getting Started
Make time to organize your thoughts and information and plan for the creation of a home health care book centered on your child.
Begin to collect and save articles, pamphlets, equipment guides and add them to the pocket of your binder (e.g., nebulizer, suction, Hoyer).
You will need...
Following are some suggestions of what you may decide to include in your book .
A "Snap Shot" of Your Child"
Health Summary or Description of Your Child's Condition
This is where you may include specific information on your child's condition. Easy-to-read definitions and descriptions will enable a new learner to quickly grasp an initial sense of your child's disability. If your child does not have a diagnosis, you can still include information on specific aspects of the disability (e.g., asthma, hypotonia).
Daily Schedule
A daily schedule will typically include waking and sleeping, information, times in and out of bed or using other equipment, times when food is given, times when the child is changed or bathed (a sample schedule is attached).
Medications
For a child on medications, a clear description of each medicine, dosage, time given and purpose are critical. Many parents and agencies also require a careful logging system to ensure precision (see attached sample).
Foods
Many children have dietary restrictions for a variety of reasons, including weight, allergies, history of aspiration and more. Parents need to be clear about what foods are to be given, when and how. Some foods may need to be prepared ahead of time and instructions for this are helpful to a new provider. If your child has special likes and dislikes for particular foods, this is also useful information.
Exercises and Therapies
If your child has specific exercises or therapies, the home health care book is a good place to keep the protocols. If a child requires range-of-motion exercises, a combination sketch or photo and description of the activity allows another person to follow-through (see sample).
Articles/Booklets of Interest
Most parents have collected favorite articles, poems, and/or booklets that they have found helpful. Sharing these with providers is a wonderful way to enhance understanding about your child.
Specialized Equipment Many children have equipment (e.g., lifts, wedges, balls, standers, suction machines, ventilators, oxygen, nebulizers) in the home. Often when a piece of equipment is initially purchased, it comes with a pamphlet describing the item. Parents can 3-hole punch these pamplets and put them in the home health care booklet. Or simply put the pamphlet in the binder's front or back pocket You may choose to take a highlighter pen and highlight the main information in each pamphlet.
Log Sheets
In addition to charting medications, some parents also like to keep track of all the child's activities of daily living. Log sheets can also be used intermittently as needed. For example, during and following a serious illness, a parent may want to closely track body temperature, respiration rate and frequency of coughs. Simple lined paper is also useful for the flow of open-ended information or story telling.
Using Your Book
Your book may now be used to:
Emergency Information All new and existing home care providers should be absolutely clear on how to act in an emergency. A list of phone numbers or pagers and an order of whom to contact first is critical. Many parents carry pagers at all times so that they can be the first contact. A list of criteria for when to call 911 versus when to call a parent may also be delineated. In addition, this section should state where the fire extinguisher, flashlight and tornado-safety area are located in the event of a natural crisis.
A Sample Daily Schedule
Please note that this schedule is skeletal and is only to provide an example of what information is important. The schedule you create for your child would be much more warm, personal, refer to your child by name and include individualized details.
Welcoming the Day
Take a Break
Lunch Time
Afternoon Rest and Relaxation
Closing the Day
Medication Log Sheet
Record of Medications
Initials of Person Providing Medication
Name:________________________ Initials_____
Name:________________________ Initials_____
All Medications
Name
Time(s) Given
Dosage
Other Information
Date
Time
Medication
Dosage
Notes
Drawing by Leslie Dickersin
Range of Motion Exercises
Low Back Rotation:
Gently bring one leg up toward her chest keeping her leg parallel with her trunk.
Hold the other leg straight on the floor. Then gently cross her flexed leg over
her extended leg. Repeat for the opposite side.
Do the following exercises when she is out of her wheelchair lying on her back
on the mat. (The shoulder flexion and head rotation exercises could also be
performed while she is in her wheelchair.) Do each exercise for 10 repetitions;
do them slowly and gently working towards the relaxation of her tone.
Reflections for Caregivers
Take Time for Response
It is the germ of creation
Take Time to Read
It is the foundation of wisdom
Take Time to Think
It is the source of strength
Take Time to Work
It is the path to patience and success
Take Time to Play
It is the secret of youth and constancy
Take Time to be Cheerful
Valuing life brings happiness
Take Time to Share
Respect is the root of true happiness
Take Time to Rejoice
Joy is the Music of the soul
Take Time for Eight Matters of the Heart
by Ed Young
From MATTERS OF THE HEART by Ed Young. Copyright c 1997 by Ed Young. Reprinted by permission of Scholastic Inc.
Ten Tips to Take Charge of Your Life